How do I talk to my Roman Catholic parents about the gospel?

Ask Pastor Mike Live

Answered on May 21, 2025 at 26:36.

Listen to this answer from 26:36

Pastor Mike’s Answer (edited)

Only God can help you with that, but I can tell you this. If I’m going to talk to a Catholic that I care about, I’m going to go to the issue of authority. Where do we derive truth from? And they’re going to say, and this is where we need to argue with them a bit, and I mean that in the most respectful way we can, with gentleness and respect. We have to argue with them about we cannot adopt the church as our source of authority. Our source of authority can’t come from tradition. It can’t come from church leaders. It has to come from the Bible. And 500 years ago, they certainly popularized the phrase in Latin, sola scriptura, for a reason. Because the scripture alone, sola, the scripture alone, right, has to be our source of authority.

Because if the church or the tradition of the church or the teaching of the church or the leaders of the church say something different than what the Bible says, then I’m going to have to go with the Bible and tell the church, well, I guess you’re wrong because clearly it says here that’s not true. So whether it’s the veneration of Mary, whether it’s purgatory, whether it’s baptismal regeneration, whether it’s the sacraments, whatever it is that they’re teaching that the merits of treasuries of the grace of Christ are all bound up and given out through the priesthood and the church, the Holy Roman Catholic Church. I’m going to say, no, we’ve got to go to the Bible to figure these things out.

And clearly, one of the best ways for you, Ryan, to prepare for conversations about authority is to go to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, which is definitely their latest doctrinal statement, and to say, okay, I’m going to start reading about what they teach regarding authority. And go to the first section of the Catechism of the Catholic Church. It’s all online. It’s all free. You don’t have to go buy a book somewhere. I just start reading the sections in the catechism of the Catholic Church about their source of authority. You can see, I’ve just got a few sections I just pulled up. Section 95, section 97. I mean, just continue to read where they say the authority cannot be the word of God alone.

And this comes just even through the counter-reformation period of the Council of Trent 450 years ago. Everyone is trying to say from the Catholic side that the authority of the church cannot be the Bible alone. It has to be the church authorities and it has to be the tradition of the church. And what we are going to do is you read through that section on authority. You’re going to have to say, hey, it can’t be both. You can’t have two authorities or in their case three authorities, tradition, magisterium, and the scriptures. You just can’t. Also, you can go to the 800 section, late 800, 890, 891. Those sections, 795, I’m just quoting a few here, where they deal with the issue of authority. And the authority of the church has to be singular.

It has to be the scripture or we’re lost. And they’ll say, oh, you’re lost. That’s why you have so many denominations. I’ll take so many denominations. And there’s plenty of them. I get it. But the divisions, right, if we’re talking about Christian denominations, are secondary. Secondary and sometimes tertiary or third-level disagreements, but not the gospel, right? I don’t care if you’re in the Calvary Chapel or this Baptist church or maybe over here, this evangelical Presbyterian church. We may disagree about a few little things here and there, but we are agreeing on what the gospel is and who Christ is. So how did we get there? We don’t have some big denominational headquarters in New York or in Milan.

No, we read the Bible, and we all come to the same conclusions about who Christ is. So, Ryan, that’s my answer to you.

Topics:

This answer has been lightly formatted from the program transcript for readability. Please refer to the audio for exact wording.

View the complete episode and transcript

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00