Ask Pastor Mike Live
Answered on May 13, 2025 at 16:20.
Listen to this answer from 16:20
Pastor Mike’s Answer (edited)
Samuel’s statement that Saul and his sons would be with him the next day does not settle Saul’s eternal destiny. In that context, it means they would soon join Samuel in the realm of the dead. The Old Testament term can refer broadly to the grave or the place of the dead without saying that every person there shares the same final condition.
Likewise, the Spirit’s departure from Saul concerned his qualification and empowerment to serve as Israel’s king. God rejected his kingship and removed the kingdom from him, but that does not by itself prove that Saul had lost every measure of grace, mercy, or forgiveness.
Neither 1 Samuel 15 nor 1 Samuel 28 gives enough information to state confidently whether Saul was saved. The most careful answer is that Scripture does not tell us his final eternal state.
Topics: Holy Spirit Old Testament Salvation Saul
This answer has been lightly formatted from the program transcript for readability. Please refer to the audio for exact wording.