Ask Pastor Mike Live
Answered on July 8, 2025 at 32:09.
Listen to this answer from 32:09
Pastor Mike’s Answer (edited)
Very specific way to say it. Let’s talk to McKenzie. McKenzie, you’re on the air with Pastor Mike Fabarez. How can I help? Hey there, Mike. How are you? Good. Yeah, my name’s McKenzie. I’m not usually here. I was just flipping through an old radio that I happened upon and stumbled upon this. And I was just listening to you talk about the concept of sacrifice and why, you know, in olden times we would sacrifice in front of God to be clean of our own sins. And I think that concept is I’m wanting to know why. Why does the innocent have to be sacrificed for the guilty spiritually? And also, does that apply to global events? Right now we’re experiencing so many children lost in Texas or you know the global wars and so many children losing their lives.
Great question. What does that all mean? Okay, let’s go back to the first part of your question. No, the innocent does not have to be punished for the guilty. Matter of fact, God could have threw up thrown up his hands and looked at McKenzie and Mike and said, "You guys are sinners. Too bad.
You’re going to wages of sin is punishment and you’re going to be punished and you will have eternal punishment for everything you’ve done based on your knowledge and based on how you know how your motives went and how what you actually did and there would be there’d be justice in the courts just like if I said if I go to Santa Ana up here where I’m at and go up the road to the courts and say here’s a guy he’s a rapist he’s a you know a thief he’s a bank robber he shot a few people that his last hold up. Yep. You know what? Does anyone need to suffer for that guy? No, that guy needs to suffer for himself. And that’s what justice would demand. So, no, innocent doesn’t have to suffer for the guilty.
I only say that to Jeff or whoever asked the question, Edund, I guess it was, because we’re saying God is so gracious and loving. The first verse most people learn, God so loved the world, he gave his only son. Why? Because we are sentenced to punishment. And God says, well, listen, the only way I could keep them not to be sent sentenced to punishment is to have Christ take the punishment upon himself. And in that sense, Christ absorbs all the punishment for you and me if we put our trust in Christ that we don’t have to have that. So yeah, no one would have to be punished for the guilty. God could have said, "Forget it." But he didn’t say, "Forget it."
because he cared enough about his creation to set up this thing called the substitutionary atonement of Christ and to have this penal substitutionary atonement take place. The fulfillment of his justice would be done by someone else suffering in their behalf. If it was just a human and we had a perfect human on the planet, that perfect human could pay for one other perfect sinful human. But we have the divine infinitely worthy human who’s also God and therefore his death can apply to multiple people. Okay, that’s why we don’t need it. We only need it if you want to not be punished and I don’t want to be punished and I hope you don’t want to be punished. So that’s why we need Christ to suffer in our place. And that’s why animals were a symbol of that.
And that got us ready for what really was, as John the Baptist said, look, here’s Christ coming, the lamb of God that takes away the sin of the world. The point is Jesus becomes the fulfillment of those human rituals or those animal ritual sacrifices of the Old Testament in this world, right? There there’s no there’s no appeasing God by anybody’s death on the planet. The reason kids died at Camp Mystic, right? In in Kerr County, Texas last week or this week or whenever it was this last week is because of Genesis 3. And God said this world, everyone is going to die. And there’s a lot of ways you can die. You can die from cancer. You could die from falling off of a camel and breaking your neck. You could die from you know old age.
You could die from whatever. But everyone’s going to die and part of the world that God created according to Romans chapter 8 and Genesis 3. I’m going to curse. He says because you guys are sinners and I’m not going to load a I’m not going to hand a loaded gun to toddlers who are sinners. And if I gave you a perfect world that worked perfectly and you’re sinners morally, well then the world would be horrific. And so he gives a broken world to people that are morally broken.
And so we got a world with all kinds of problems all the way down to the cellular level of our lives and our bodies even to you know meteorological events and flash floods and earthquakes in our part of the world and tornadoes in the middle of the country and all the problems that we have in the world are because God said this world is now subject to futility which includes all kinds of things that are going to happen includes people’s death and like Israel that sounds like at least That was a nuance of your question. Israel goes in.
Well, number one, here comes Hamas taking hostages, killing people at a music conference concert and takes them hostage and kidnaps them into their country and then hides behind you know, schools and hospitals and goes into their tunnels and Israel, right, is probably one of the most exacting, careful war machines on the planet. They’re not as strong as the United States, but they are careful and they do the best they can. Are people going to die? Yes, lots of people die. You can call that collateral damage, which sounds very heartless, but the reality is they’ve done the best they can to go in and try and fix the problem. Just like if 40,000 people in the United States were taken hostage and 200,000 were killed, which might be proportionally close.
I don’t know. I haven’t done the math. We might go scorched earth on Canada or or Mexico or whoever did that lived next to us and we would we probably I guarantee you wouldn’t be as exacting as Israel has been. So people are dying to try and rectify the problem. If we let Hamas or any other terrorist group that wants to annihilate Israel take them off the map, then here’s the problem. Israel is going to be taken off the map. If the United States didn’t intervene to go and deal with the nuclear power of Iran, then I guarantee you all it needed was more time until they launched their nukes and destroyed Israel. That’s their whole point. They have said it. It’s in their charter. That’s what they chant every day. They’re doing it in Dearbornne, Michigan.
They’re doing it in mosques across our country. They certainly are doing it in the Gaza Strip and they’re doing it in Samaria today in the West Bank as as they call it. And they are telling people Israelis are rats. They need to die. We’re going to cut their heads off. And they’re teaching kids that in in kindergarten. Why? Because sin is a problem. Sin needs to be rectified. Those kids need to repent. Their parents need to repent. We need to repent. The Israelis need to repent. We all need to put our trust in Christ. And Christ can then bring moderate peace in the interim. We won’t have perfection. Even the best Christian couple has marital problems from time to time. But we’d have a better world.
Problem is Jesus said, "Not everyone’s going to rightly respond to me. They’re not going to repent of their sins." So you’re going to have in this world a really messy place with wars, rumors of wars, pestilence, earthquakes, all kinds of disease and death. You’re going to have all kinds of problems in this world. But take heart, I’ve overcome the world. So the job for you and I is to look at a messed up world with messed up bodies, with messed up wars and messed up things and death all over the place and say, I want a better life.
I want something like CS Lewis wrote about in in mere Christianity which has been a pivotal book for a lot of people to say what we really want right is something that God has prepared for us in the Bible and constantly talks about over the horizon of this life. That’s why prosperity preachers are an absolute car. They’re a joke. They’re trying to say you can have all the things the Bible talks about in the future. You can have those now. You can’t have those now. Impossible. In this world you’ll have tribulation. Take heart. I’ve overcome the world. So kids are going to continue to die. Teenagers are going to continue to die. People at 7-Eleven get in the middle of a holdup are going to continue to die.
You and I are going to get diseases and continue to fall apart and die. And that’s all a part of the fact that we can have before God a new world that he’s going to usher in. And the only reason he’s waiting is for more people listening to my voice right now and every other set of ears around the world responding rightly to the gospel. So that’s why we as Christians are so missionary minded. We want more people to hear the gospel. Now, I yacked for a long time. McKenzie, your turn now. Tell me what you mean and if I came close to responding to what you mean, and if not, let’s go round two. So, talk to me, McKenzie. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you for your perspective. There’s a lot to unpack there.
I’m glad that I’m recording that and you might get another call from me
Topics: Atonement Sacrifices Sin Suffering
This answer has been lightly formatted from the program transcript for readability. Please refer to the audio for exact wording.